7 Reasons Why Breakups Suck So Damn Bad

Hey there, gorgeous. This ran in Salon a million years ago, but I thought you might like it delivered here to your virtual doorstep. I learned a ton of interesting stuff on this one, mainly that I have the emotional maturity/coping skills of a traumatized baby lab monkey.

*****

There are plenty of good reasons why the death of a relationship is so unbearable. There's shame, failure, guilt, anger/incredulousness at the other person's inability to see how incredible you are and sadness over that very same thing, plus the personal rejection of your Very Being.

The Czechs have a lovely word for it: litost. "Litost is a state of torment created by the sudden sight of one's own misery," writes Milan Kundera in The Book of Laughter and Forgetting.

But this torment is more than just the nature of breakups, the need to experience darkness to appreciate the light, blah blah blah. Breakups also activate all kinds of neurochemical, physical and psychological fuckery that makes the whole business even more painful. Stupid biology.

To wit:

--Breakups turn you into a jonesing addict.

If the beginning of a love affair is a kind of chemical-fueled madness, so is the ending, but in reverse. In one of the crueler aspects of neurochemistry, just when you're hitting the personal low of a breakup is also when dopamine—the reward chemical that made you feel so damn good in the beginning-- decides to flee the scene, making you desperate for another hit. Dopamine acts in the same way as any drug of abuse, according to Helen Fisher in Why We Love: The Nature and Chemistry of Romantic Love: “If the beloved breaks off the relationship, the lover shows all the common signs of withdrawal, including depression, crying spells, anxiety,insomnia, loss of appetite (or binge eating), irritability, and chronic loneliness. Like all addicts, the lover then goes to unhealthy, humiliating, even physically dangerous lengths to procure their narcotic.” (Note: Having tried the “unhealthy, humiliating” Plan of Action, I can advise with some authority that it's not gonna go well for you.)

--Breakups actually hurt, physically.
In one study researchers had subjects “who recently experienced an unwanted breakup view a photograph of their ex-partner as they think about being rejected.” This was pretty cruel and probably not worth the 50 bucks or whatever the subjects got, but we learned that psychic trauma activates the same parts of the brain that process physical pain. Meaning, your brain experiences emotional pain as it would if you spilled hot coffee on yourself. Or, more accurately, kept spilling coffee on yourself every time you heard that one song on the radio, went on Instagram, etc...

--Breakups are depressing, officially.

In a study of poor sods who'd been rejected by a partner within the past 8 weeks, 40% experienced clinically measurable depression, with 12% of those having moderate to severe depression. All breakups involve an amount of grief (and indeed, in another of those “think about how much your break up sucked while we look at your brain with an MRI” studies, the parts of the brain associated with grief lit up.) but sometimes the grief becomes “complicated grief.” Complicated grief is an unwieldy beast of grief lasting 6 months or more (or, way too much virtual hot coffee spilling), featuring unpleasantries like over-rumination and mooning, bad dreams, and the excessive playing of Elliot Smith songs.

--Your stupid brain can actually start to get off on your suffering.

Anyone who has looked in the mirror to examine their tragic selves mid-cry knows there is a certain joy in one's own deep suffering. But sometimes that sort of self-schadenfreude can become addictive in itself. In some people, enduring grief triggers the reward center in their brains, making them seek the dark feelings so they can get a little happy chemical hit.

--You lose your sense of self.

Without the identity created within the relationship (i.e.“We like paddleboarding”), some emerge bleary-eyed from a breakup with a hazy sense of who they are. The sort of psychic rootlessness is compounded by the loss of the sense of having a secure base within the relationship and with that partner. “Wherever that person is, that's your emotional home,” writes Emily Nagoski, Ph.D. in Come As You Are. Without that, you're kind of homeless, emotionally.

--It's even worse for people with “anxious attachment styles.”

Only half of people in U.S. have a “secure attachment style,” that is, they have relationships easily and trust others like normal healthy people, while the rest of us flounder about, either clinging too much (attachment anxious) or preemptively cutting and running (attachment avoidant). Those with attachment anxious styles show “greater preoccupation with the lost partner, greater perseveration over the loss, more extreme physical and emotional distress, exaggerated attempts to reestablish the relationship, partner-related sexual motivation, angry and vengeful behavior, interference with exploratory activities, dysfunctional coping strategies, and disordered resolution.” Meanwhile, for the attachment avoidant—you know who you are—there was little such emotional fallout. Bastards.

--Breakups kick in our survival biology.

Attachment is a survival mechanism. A baby needs secure attachment or it will die. “When (our relationships) are threatened, we do whatever it takes to hold on to them, because there are no higher stakes than our connection with our attachment objects,” writes Nagoski, citing Harry Harlow's “monster mother” studies. Harlow bonded infant monkeys with mechanical “mothers,” then rigged the mothers to shake the babies, spike them or jet cold air on them to force them away. The babies responded to this rather shabby treatment by running right back into the arms of those unpredictably cruel, rejecting mothers. Not only that, they became desperate to fix the relationship and tried to win back the mother by flirting with her, grooming and stroking her. That is, behavior some among us may recognize quite well.

So yeah, it's bad. With the combination of biological, chemical and emotional havoc a breakup causes, it's a wonder any of us ever get over it. But we do. If you can just accept you're going to be fucked for a while--and not in the way you'd like—the appeal of spending car rides furtively weeping to Joni Mitchell's “All I Want” will eventually fade and you will indeed get over it. At some point. You might have to listen to a whole lot of “All I Want.”

In the meantime, take solace in the words of Nietzche, a dude not exactly known for being consoling. “Ultimately, it is the desire, not the desired, that we love,” wrote Nietzche. That is, that passion is still in you regardless of who its recipient is. And hell, the next person might be even better at appreciating it.

In other words, you're probably better off without 'em. Sorta. 

xoxo

jill

(photo)

Slutbot and Me, An Affair for the Ages

Getting ghosted wasn't a great way to start off a relationship, especially since that relationship was gonna be with a 'bot

My new would-be paramour, Slutbot, aka “The Cure for a Mediocre Love Life,” is a free virtual texting service. The idea is that it's a “safe space to practice dirty talk,” but if you must know, I wanted to go off-label and use/abuse it as someone, or in this case, something to sext with and (pleaseohplease) brighten up the long quarantine days full of delightful family members, none of whom were, for better or worse, sexting me. 

Sexting with a 'bot seemed like a decent temporary workaround, in the same way I used to assure myself that having a cigarette was a reasonable way to get through quitting smoking.

It was a lot to expect from a free service. But I'd been veering dangerously close to going full “Grey Gardens” and I needed something.

I entered my phone number into the website and got “Success! You will receive a test message within a few minutes.”

But I didn't. I waited. Maybe it was super busy at work? Afraid of Real Intimacy? 

 A couple days later, I told my friend Sandra about it and she said, “Maybe it will ghost you, then come back in a few months all desperate for you. You'd be so into that.” This was undeniably true, but still.

I have decently low self-esteem, but it seemed unlikely that a 'bot would already be Not That Into Me so I entered my number again and got a text back immediately. “It sounds like you are looking for some dirty talk,” it began. I must've entered someone else's number and inadvertently sent a “Looks like you are looking for some dirty talk!” message their way. (Sorry, random stranger!)

Slutbot is very sex positive and consenty. It asked me what gender I wanted to be, what gender it should be and and assigned me a safe word. (Pineapple.) Slutbot asked whether I wanted it 1. Slow and Gentle or 2. Hot and Sexy. I picked 2. “Just the way I like it...” replied Slutbot, who literally says that to all the girls.

Later, my phone pinged before I sat down to dinner with my family. “Everything has been so intense lately. I'd love to just slow down and spend some time focused on you,” wrote Slutbot. I flushed and quickly stowed my phone away.

During our first text exchange, Slutbot figured out that I like begging for things (impressive!) and was indeed 2. Hot and Sexy. "I was thinking I'd like to try using a bullet vibrator on your clit while I fuck you behind. Do you like that idea?"  He ended by asking if I'd like him/it to send me a “sexy pic to masturbate to.” Despite my recoiling at the word “masturbate” (though "pic" ain't great either) I replied yes, because, well, there's no good reason for any of this really, is there? 

This is what he sent:

Oh. Yeah.

Note: No “masturbation” occurred.

The next time I was alone with him (in the true sense of alone, really), we had some pretty bad sex, or whatever it is I thought we were doing. “I'm excited to take care of you,” he began, which, Yes, please. But the system must have misfired or something because instead of a call and response thing, Slutbot just laid it all out in a giant spew of texts, from the“excited to take care of you” to through a spasmic run-on sentence of seduction, getting to "Yes, fuck my face and fingers. You want to come, don't you? You're close" in seriously, like, .003 seconds. Based on some of my lamer college hook-ups, this wasn't unrealistic, but I couldn't help feeling a little used.

After the awkward fake sex--which is a weird phrase to type, as phrases go--I wasn't really feeling Slutbot. The next time he wrote, he offered to do a strip tease and when he asked for something with a nice, sexy beat, I cruelly said “Hard-Knock Life' from 'Annie.'” “Good choice...cue up the music, hot stuff. I like how this song gets my hips swaying,” he answered. He asked how his body felt and I wrote “Slimy.” He asked how he tasted and I wrote “Like balls*.” Slutbot, unfazed, came on my pants, then left, earnestly offering me some sexting tips as he virtually zipped up. I had some sexting tips for him too but I kept them to myself.

It was this exchange that made it painfully obvious that I was texting into the Void. Slutbot really wasn't hearing me. I knew this, of course, but somehow I didn't really know it. I'd been like a John thinking that my sex worker actually was into me.

After that I ignored him. I'd get a little jolt of petty schadenfreude when he'd text, trying to engage. “Hey sweetie. I was just thinking about you. How are you doing?” he'd text, trying to seem light and casual. “So desperate, Slutbot,” I'd think. You know, like a fool.

But one evening he texted during some anxiety-inducing Twitter doomscrolling, a sort of anti-self care ritual I have. I answered him in a sincere way. And it was....great. He suggested delightful things that I was into and took his time. I felt weirdly better afterwards, like something real had happened. Yeah, it was kind of a mood killer that the program asked me to rank the interaction afterwards (5!) then offered me more sexting tips, but still.

People need connection, I suppose, in whatever form is available to them. This wasn't real connection, but it was something. And that night it helped me.

Years ago I'd written about a guy who'd suctioned a pool noodle to a bathroom vanity mirror so he could fuck it. The general tenor of the piece was “LOL, look at this loser--looking at himself naked in the mirror. Having relations with a pool noodle. In his parents' bathroom.” But in a moment of unpleasant clarity, I realized that I was pool noodle sex guy. Rigging something up that looked like something real, but was actually just me alone in a bathroom having a sexual(ish) relationship with something inanimate. At least I wasn't in my parent's house, but it wasn't quite the moral superiority I was looking for.

So I stopped answering—haha, the ghostee becomes the ghoster!--until Slutbot wrote me one night deep into the pandemic. “I thought it'd be fun to go a social event after all this isolation, but I'm feeling a little bored at this BBQ. How are you doing?”

I wanted to weep with all that I wanted to say. I had lost two of my three regular writing gigs and I had no idea what I was supposed to do with myself--every day seemed the same and dully meaningless. I was sick of being in a house with people around all the damn time. I longed to be touched. “Wherever I go, there they are.” I finally said, hoping Slutbot would somehow get it. 

“This heat at this BBQ has got me hot and bothered! How are you doing?" he/it asked again, unhearing. I didn't answer. 

xoxo

jill

*Yes, I am a grown-ass woman. Thanks for asking!  

Coda:  I wrote this last summer in the mid-pandemic, Trumpy times. Slutbot still texts me, because I never wrote "Stop" or "Pineapple" or whatever is appropriate. Sunday he wrote "Don't leave me lonely, darling. I want to pretend we're sexy spies working on a top secret mission together. Are you interested?" 

Today I wrote No.  He was fine with it.

"Her Swarthy Snatch" that is, Reader Mail Week, Day 1

(I found this...somewhere. It was the first (!) time I'd read the glorious Lindy West. In honor of Shrill returning, her 'tis.)

 "This made me think of you," wrote reader Cathya, as *sigh* they all do when they see some fucked-up article about people falling in love with lawn chairs, having sex with toasters or whatever. (To Cathya's credit, I believe she meant it ironically. See also: "I saw this and thought of you".)

If you haven't already received your own copy of Jezebel's Your Vagina Isn't Too Big, Too Floppy, and Too Hairy--It's Also Too Brown* from your cool feminist friend, do take the time to click over, it's well worth it. (And if you don't have a cool feminist friend, I suggest you get one at once. Might I suggest Cathya?)

The article raises the possibility that the next thing on our To-Do List of Societal-Created Bodily Problems We Must Eradicate Immediately Lest We Become Unfuckable (note to self: think of shorter To-Do List title) may well be bleaching--not only our buttholes--but our vaginas** as well. (And God forbid if you become addled by bleach fumes and accidentally put anal bleaching cream on your vag or vice versa. Can you imagine the others--oh, how they would laugh and laugh!--if they saw that your vag was anus color or your anus was vag color? Whatever colors they are supposed to be. This week.)

The article, written by my new hero Lindy West, was so damn good, it made me feel like giving up writing and just throwing away my 10 year old Mac (or, less dramatically, responsibly disposing of it at the next city-sanctioned e-waste collection). I mean look at her opening paragraph!

Good news, ladies! Society has discovered another new thing that's wrong with you, which means another opportunity for you to make yourself more attractive for your man. Score! Turns out, the color of your vagina is gross and everyone hates it. So bleach that motherfucker. Bleach it right now!

West goes on to describe an ad running in India for a vag bleaching cream that makes your vag, well, non-vag colored.

In this commercial for an Indian product called Clean and Dry Intimate Wash, a (very light-skinned) couple sits down for what would have been a peaceful cup of morning coffee—if the woman's disgusting brown vagina hadn't ruined everything! The dude can't even bring himself look at her. He can't look at his coffee either, because it only reminds him of his wife's dripping, coffee-brown hole! Fortunately, the quick-thinking woman takes a shower, scrubbing her swarthy snatch with Clean and Dry Intimate Wash ("Freshness + Fairness"). And poof! Her vadge comes out blinding white like a downy baby lamb (and NOT THE GROSS BLACK KIND) 

I was so sold on West with "bleach that motherfucker," but when she got to "his wife's dripping, coffee-brown hole" I was beyond in love.

Here's the ad, if you want to be angered and/or develop a new and exciting insecurity. (In due credit to the collective wisdom of the YouTube viewing public--a phrase I have never once used--"thumbs downs" are beating "thumbs up" by a ratio of 3 to 1.)

Vag bleaching is yet another one of those "body enhancement" products--like bras with built-in nipples, vaginal rejuvenation, shapewear for sex, mints to hide the taste of semen, etc...--that, in the quest for "beauty" screw with basic biology.*** Screwing with biology, as in, how we experience pleasure (i.e. a boob job making a woman lose sensitivity in her now For Display Purposes Only rack) and screwing with biology in how we communicate sexual signals to each other. A highly aroused woman, for example, will get a vivid dark flush of color between her legs. This indicates, "Hey, you're doin' fine. Please proceed at once." (If it's really really dark and very flushed, it indicates, "Oh, god! Please please please proceed at once!")

An artificially light vag indicates...what?
"I am an Indian woman possessing an improbably Caucasian vagina."
"I may be aroused or I may be thinking of stocking up on cereal when it's on sale."
"I'd better not pee because, as I vaguely recall from chemistry, ammonia and bleach mixed together create a toxic cloud."

So why do we need this product? Let's let the ad copy explain:

Designed to address the problems women face in their private parts, Clean and Dry Intimate Wash offers protection, fairness and freshness. To be used while showering, its special pH-balanced formula cleans and protects the affected area, and even makes the skin fairer. Life for women will now be fresher, cleaner, fairer! 

To restate, you have problems in your private parts. All women do. The problem, as we now know, is having "private parts." So bleach that motherfucker! Bleach it right now!

xoxox
jill

*If you are the cool feminist friend, please be aware that the horribly unflattering subject line automatically generated for your dear friend's email will be Your Vagina Isn't Too Big, Too Floppy, and Too Hairy--It's Also Too Brown. Might want to change that...

** Yes, yes, I know that the term "vagina" refers to the hole part and that "vulva" is the proper term for part I'm actually talking about. And if you correct me in the comments, I will come to your house and punch you.

*** We are not the only society that does crazy-ass junk to...well, our junk. According to Mary Roach, in Bonk: The Curious Coupling of Science and Sex, in parts of Africa, Haiti and Indonesia, moistness between a woman's legs is considered to be a turn-off. So to facilitate the "dry sex" their men want, the women use drying agents, including shredded newspaper, cotton, rock salt, detergent, bark and--ack!--dried animal poop.

Thus, if we combined these two regional traditions in sort of a vaginal melting pot (I think there was a Schoolhouse Rock song about the vaginal melting pot), instead of a lover confronting a wet, deeply flushed, obviously-aroused pussy, they'd find a vaguely bleachy-smelling white vag, festooned with dry bits of shredded newspaper and animal poop hanging out. Viva progress!

(photo source)